Locale (Yuc,MX): Cochinita Pibil

This is one I’ve been excited to make. I think I bit off a little more than I could chew, but I sure was going to give it my best shot. This all started on work travel, where at one restaurant, they raved about their cochinita pibil. I thought I knew my way around Mexican food, but this one had some seriously powerful flavor. I went back a second time a few months later, and they had already sold out for the day. I needed some more in my life, so let’s do it.


Cochinita Pibil | Chile Tamulado | K’uut Bi Ik


The Prep Table

The credit to these recipes goes to Kenji over at Serious Eats. No shame, I used ’em verbatim. Links are above, check ’em out. Ain’t getting any clickthrough credit or anything, just appreciation for his recipes and giving credit where due.

A whole lot going on here.

We’re going to make two salsas, in addition to a banana-leaf wrapped pork butt. The pork itself is flavorful, but not spicy. And you know I need spicy. When you look at the picture above, you’re seeing a very tame marinade – cinnamon, annatto, onion, garlic, fruit. It’s a power marinade for sure.

Quick pickled onions are essential. I’ve made these a ton in the past, I’ve thrown jalapeno in there, I’ve done habanero. We’re going to have quite a bit of heat, so we’re going mild with jalapenos. Make a brining liquid and let those sit in the fridge.

A relatively simple salsa recipe, which also packs a punch was the K’uut Bi Ik. Toast and blend. I have to wait til MrsForensicBBQ is out of the house, or I’m going to the garage to make anything this spicy. I don’t remember what happened on this exact day. I think I got scolded though. These salsas tend to linger. I think I left a lid or something in the sink and caught holy hell. Deservedly so.

If it wasn’t the K’uut Bi Ik that got me yelled at, it was the Chile Tamulado. This one I was especially excited for because I love the habanero pepper so much. And this was a lot of ’em. You know I made the Rick Bayless salsa before, this is spicier with a little citrus. So freakin good. I told you, this was a mega post.


The Process

Toasted spices

This was already magical and I didn’t even go anywhere yet. The kitchen was smelling delightful. We had peppercorns, achiote, oregano, cloves, cinnamon, allspice. A very fragrant cook so far.

Mix with the liquids

Post toast, we’re combining with the acids and the soy sauce.. Add in that garlic that I toasted during the salsa cook. Gave it a hearty blend. This is where I had to improvise a little bit. I cut this pork butt up into three sections and threw that thick marinade into the bags. We let this go overnight and the experience was about to begin.

Marinaded
This part was fun

The next day, we threw a pork butt chunk onto a banana leaf. We topped it with some fresh onion, tomato, and some jalapeno. Threw a bay leaf on there and then the not so fun part – the wrapping of the banana leaf. This was more frustrating than anything. These things split every which way, but I did my best. Those Yucatan-natives, enjoy making fun of this guy. But I gave it my best.

Let ’em rest in that smoky chamber and get ready for some damn good pork.


The Result

Was late, pictures aren’t great

When the temperature probes like butter, get ’em outta there and chop it up. I’ll leave the text out for the new few, enjoy the photos.

Shred
Plated

Knowing this was going to be my big 2026 post, we went homemade on the tortillas. We threw a side of beans and rice and then scooped the pork a top the torts. Topped only with the pickled red onion (and maybe a jalapeno from the jar). I tried to keep the salsas to a minimum, because I was going to have a rough exit with these already. But damn this was good. For round one, it worked, it was delicious, and know it will only get better. Unlike last week, I will make this one again. I plated this up to give to some colleagues, and they said that salsa was way too hot for anyone (his words), but that the pork was killer. Because it was.

Cochinita Pibil – excellent use of a pork butt.. can’t wait to enjoy this again!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top